SAY NO TO TOXIC PLASTIC CARPETS
SAY NO TO TOXIC PLASTIC CARPETS
SIGN OUR PETITION FOR HEALTHY AND SAFE PLAYING FIELDS!
“To this point, no companies in the U.S. can fully recycle them, according to a turf trade association president.”
“It's being shipped overseas. It's being dumped in fields in Pennsylvania and wetlands in Maryland and Massachusetts,” said Kyla Bennett, science policy director for Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility. “I do not know anyone who's [disposing of fields] properly, because it cannot be done properly.”
“PFAS, or “forever chemicals,” which are used in the artificial turf manufacturing process and are present in the finished product, are linked to a range of serious health consequences including reproductive disorders, thyroid dysfunction and cancers.
There is no “safe” level of exposure to benzene, PFAS or lead: all have negative health consequences at every level and children playing on artificial turf are exposed to all of them. “ - Dr. Philip Landrigan & Brita Lundberg
“Natural Grass is a safer, softer, more reliable surface to send kids out to play on”
- Abby Wombach
Question: “ Can you tell me how many synthetic fields have been recycled in the United States?”
Industry Rep Answer: “None.”
“The release of PFAS during the manufacturing of this material together with the release of PFAS during the decomposition in a landfill should also be considered. Although there is some advocacy for recycling this material at end-of-life, there are currently no known facilities that will perform this process for artificial turf.” - NJ DEP
ARTIFICIAL TURF
THE FACTS:
Synthetic turf contains microplastics, PFAs, PAHs, carcinogens, neurotoxins, and heavy metals that are toxic for people and wildlife.
Synthetic turf is an impervious surface per EPA: “Impervious Surface- Any surface that prevents or significantly impedes the infiltration of water into the underlying soil. This can include but is not limited to: roads, driveways, parking areas and other areas created using non porous material; buildings, rooftops,
structures, artificial turf and compacted gravel or soil.”
Synthetic turf may leach chemicals into the ground and groundwater, cause microplastic pollution, and serious pollution concerns during the manufacturing process exist.
Synthetic turf raises the ground temperature between 20 – 40 degrees Fahrenheit. This is unsustainable given current rising temperatures.
There are questions regarding the potential link between artificial turf and Glioblastomas (brain tumors) in six Philadelphia Phillies baseball players.
Studies indicate that artificial turf causes more musculoskeletal injuries, concussions, and strain than natural grass.
Synthetic turf has a terrible carbon footprint and as an impervious surface is inferior to natural grass for storm water retention.
Artificial turf Is expensive to install and is not eligible for state aid.
Maplewood, Westfield and Scotch Plains, NJ, residents recently voted NO on artificial turf. Residents in Ridgewood, Rutherford, East Orange, and Maplewood are fighting similar plans.
Artificial turf has been banned in several communities and legislation proposing moratoriums is being proposed in other localities, and the EU is also restricting microplastics in artificial turf.
WHAT EXPERTS SAY:
Mount Sinai Children's Environmental Health Center has written to the Montclair Public School District and the Montclair Board of Education to advise against the installation of synthetic turf of any kind "due to the uncertainties surrounding the safety of these products and the potential for dangerous heat and chemical exposures."
National Center for Health Research strongly urges against these toxic materials. “Chemicals that are banned from children’s toys are in artificial turf and rubber playground surfaces.”
Synthetic turf cannot be recycled. The non-profit Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER) has filed a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission accusing the makers and marketers of artificial turf of deceptive and unfair advertising for claims it can be recycled.
NJDEP has issued multiple memos regarding concerns about artificial turf.
The GREEN ACRES (pg. 40) program has updated its guidance to include an artificial turf addendum to help guide applicants. The addendum states that:
“Turf type should be evaluated to address potential ecosystem contamination.
Synthetic turf fields can increase the ambient temperature of the neighborhood, especially in highly developed areas.
Synthetic turf fields have been shown to have elevated surface temperatures, which can increase the risk of heat-related injuries, especially in children. Applicants are strongly encouraged to design projects so that adjacent shade trees are preserved whenever possible, additional shade trees are planted, and/or shade structures are provided to mitigate this risk.
"New Jersey has some of the most widespread PFAS contamination in the US, with an estimated more than 500,000 residents drinking contaminated tap water.Recent actions by the USEPA highlight increasing recognition that there is no safe level of PFAS exposure. On March 14, 2023, USEPA proposed National Primary Drinking Water Regulations for six PFAS, dramatically lowering the recommended levels of PFOA and PFOS and citing scientific evidence of health impacts at drinking water levels close to zero.These guidelines also include advisories for newer PFAS chemicals PFNA, GenX, PFBS, and PFHxS. In addition to drinking water regulations, steps have been taken to designate PFAS hazardous substances and restrict their use in certain products both at the federal and state level. To allow the installation of PFAS-containing surfaces would be extremely short-sighted as further restrictions and regulations on these chemicals are likely to come.” — Mount Sinai Children's Environmental Health Center
“The Children’s Environmental Health Center of the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai strongly discourages the installation of artificial turf playing surfaces and fields due to the uncertainties surrounding the safety of these products and the potential for dangerous heat and chemical exposures.” - Sarah Evans, PhD, MPH, Environmental Medicine and Public Health, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai
To read the letter in full, click here.
Artificial Turf in The News
As Climate Change Fears Grow, a Real Fight Over Fake Turf
A city’s decision to replace actual grass with a synthetic version sets off a conflict over the possible environmental and health risks of the move.
— New York Times
Scotch Plains, Westfield voters reject turf field projects
“Opponents of the project had cited the cost, environmental concerns and changes to the character of the park.”
— MyCentralJersey.com
Our community has been deceived’: Turf wars mount over PFAS
“...testing performed by a local advocacy group found organic fluorine in the field, an indicator that it might contain PFAS. ”
— Politico
Articles/Studies/News:
NYTimes: As Climate Change Fears Grow, a Real Fight Over Fake Turf
Scotch Plains, Westfield voters reject turf field projects/
Politico: ‘Our community has been deceived’: Turf wars mount over PFAS
'Goal posts moved': Portsmouth officials walk back claim PFAS is not in turf field
EPA: Our Current Understanding of the Human Health and Environmental Risks of PFAS
The Intercept: Toxic PFAS Chemicals Found in Artificial Turf
EWG: California makes strides to ban toxic ‘forever chemicals’ in artificial turf
The Guardian: Boston bans artificial turf in parks due to toxic ‘forever chemicals’
ESPN: NFLPA: New injury data shows grass 'significantly safer' than turf
AAP: Synthetic Playing Fields for Sports May Pose Increased Risk of Concussion in Youth
FORBES: Ground Zero: The Dangers That Artificial Turf May Pose To Football Players' Brains
NPR: After Aaron Rodgers' injury, experts sound the alarm about the risks of artificial turf
EWG: New Studies Show PFAS in Artificial Grass Blades and Backing
TURI: Athletic Playing Fields - Selecting Safer Alternatives
Boston Globe: Toxic chemicals are found in blades of artificial turf
Safe Healthy Playing Fields: Toxicity
STUDY: Health impacts of artificial turf: Toxicity studies, challenges, and future directions
BEYOND PLASTICS: Synthetic Turf is HAZARDOUS
NEWSWEEK: Your Kids Might Be Playing on Toxic Chemicals
MOMS CLEAN AIR FORCE : Artificial Grass Isn’t Always Greener: Toxic Chemicals in Synthetic Turf
Associated Press: What does the science say about the grass vs. turf debate in sports?
NCHR: Injuries Related to Artificial Turf
REUTERS: Turf wars: The courtroom battle over artificial turf safety may be closer than we think
NEW SCIENTIST: Athletes may have higher risk of concussion on artificial grass
Synthetic Turf: Industry's Claims Versus the Science
STUDY: Health Impacts of Artificial Turf: Toxicity Studies, Challenges, and Future Directions
Opinion: Pediatricians Warn That Synthetic Turf Is Especially Dangerous For Children And Teens
NJ.com: Turf wars raging as N.J. residents face off over replacing grass with artificial fields
PBS: Clashes over grass playing fields versus artificial surfaces
CBS: Decision To Replace Grass With Artificial Turf At Columbian Park In East Orange Sparks Debate
Sunnyvale officials nix artificial turf on athletic field - San José Spotlight
Wayland Must Develop a Multi-year Grass Field Rehabilitation Plan
How Plastic Waste is Hurting Your Health | American Lung Association
Environmental toxicity and decomposition of polyethylene - ScienceDirect
Petrochemical Pollution and Our Health
Plastic pollution is an environmental injustice to vulnerable communities
Turf recycler hit with environmental violations as it works to open PA plant
“Lead was found in synthetic turf fields in New Jersey at levels so high that several fields had to be closed by the New Jersey State Department of Health. This is extremely alarming since lead is a highly toxic chemical and brain injury is the most serious consequence of pediatric lead poisoning. Young children are especially vulnerable to lead because their brains are rapidly growing and developing, and because their normal hand-to-mouth behavior increases the risk that they will take lead into their bodies from the environment. Even low-dose exposure to lead can cause loss of IQ, shortening of attention span and disruption of behavior as well as increased risk of dyslexia and school failure.” - Dr. Landrigan
“In addition to the health risks to school children and athletes, approximately three tons of infill materials migrate off of each synthetic turf field into the greater environment each year. About 2-5 metric tons of infill must be replaced every year for each field, meaning that tons of the infill have migrated off the field into grass, water, and our homes. The fields also continuously shed microplastics as the plastic blades break down. These materials may contain additives such as PAHs, flame retardants, and UV inhibitors, which can be toxic to marine and aquatic life. Microplastics are known to migrate into the oceans, the food chain, and drinking water, and they can absorb and concentrate other toxins from the environment.
Synthetic surfaces also create heat islands. In contrast, organically managed natural grass saves energy by dissipating heat, cooling the air, and reducing energy to cool nearby buildings. Natural grass and soil protect groundwater quality; biodegrade polluting chemicals and bacteria; reduce surface water runoff; abate noise; and reduce glare.” - Diana Zuckerman, Ph.D. , President, National Center for Health Research